Drug companies are creating a new medical disorder known as
"female sexual dysfunction" in order to build markets for drugs
among women, despite controversy surrounding the medicalization of sexual
problems, said an article in the BMJ (formerly, the British
Medical Journal).
Over the past six years, researchers with close ties to the
pharmaceutical industry have been developing and defining the new disorder
at company sponsored meetings, wrote journalist, Ray Moynihan.
One of the milestones in the making of the new disorder was a Journal
of the American Medical Association (JAMA) article in February 1999,
which suggested that 43% of women aged 18-59 have female sexual
dysfunction. However, leading researchers have raised serious concerns
about this figure, describing it as misleading and potentially dangerous.
Many researchers believe that portraying sexual difficulties as a
dysfunction will encourage doctors to prescribe drugs that change sexual
function, when attention should be paid to other aspects of a woman's
life. It's also likely to make women think they have a malfunction when
they do not. But perhaps the greatest concern is the ever-narrowing
definitions of "normal" that help turn the complaints of the
healthy into the conditions of the sick, Moynihan warned.
Although corporate-sponsored creation of a disease is not a new
phenomenon, the role of drug companies in the construction and promotion
of new conditions needs more public scrutiny, he concluded.
The problem was exposed last year by Dr. Madeline Behrendt, a
practicing chiropractor and chair of the Council on Women's Health of the
World Chiropractic Alliance. The trend to categorize normal female body
functions as diseases has generated billions of dollars for the medical
and pharmaceutical industries, but has done little to solve women's health
problems, according to Dr. Behrendt's findings, published in the Journal
of Vertebral Subluxation Research.
Her paper examined the biases towards women's health in the
male-dominated research world and asserted that there is a growing
resentment by women whose health problems are disregarded by researchers
-- even as they are being exploited by the drug and medical industries.
"Drugs are now utilized to interfere with the multiple bodily
experiences unique to womanhood such as menstruation," Behrendt
stated. The creation of medical specialties such as female sexual
dysfunction, PMS, fertility and menopause are further evidence of this
growing problem, she added. Currently, more than 300 drugs geared
specifically to women are being researched.
SOURCES: "The making of a disease: female sexual
dysfunction," BMJ, January 4, 2003.
"The Role and Relationship of Chiropractic and Women's Health
Issues - A Call for Research," Madeline Behrendt, D.C., Journal of
Vertebral Subluxation Research, October 2000.